Thursday 12 November 2026 Archive edition · go to today's edition NL EN FR
← World
WorldMedia

Trump's multibillion claim against the BBC over an edited speech can go ahead, although one of its two parts falls away

A Florida judge finds the defamation complaint over the Panorama programme sufficiently argued to proceed, but has not yet ruled on the merits.

· latest source update wo · 3 sources · CBS News, PBS NewsHour, La Libre
Illustration for this article

US federal judge Jeffrey Kuntz in Florida on Tuesday rejected the BBC's request to have Donald Trump's defamation case thrown out, CBS News and La Libre report. Trump is seeking 10 billion dollars: 5 billion for defamation and 5 billion for breaching a Florida law on unfair trade practices. The judge did dismiss that second part, the AP news agency, via PBS, and La Libre write. Whether Trump can prove his claims and the damage he suffered will be decided at a later stage.

The case centres on a report by the BBC programme Panorama, broadcast a week before the 2024 presidential election. According to Trump's lawyers, cited by CBS News, two passages from his speech of 6 January 2021 that were 55 minutes apart were edited together, dropping his call for peaceful protest. According to La Libre, the judge found that, given the time between the two passages, the BBC knew or should have known the edit was not accurate. The BBC already apologised for the edit in November 2025, and its director-general and head of news stepped down.

Trump called it a major victory on Truth Social. A BBC spokesperson told CBS News the broadcaster was surprised but respects the court's authority and remains confident in its position. According to PBS, BBC lawyer Charles Tobin complained that Trump has still not been deposed, with two months left for the exchange of evidence. Another judge in Miami has ordered Trump to sit for questioning by BBC lawyers before 11 December, although his team has said he is only available in January.

Spotted a mistake in this article? Let us know.